Real Estate Seller Disputes in Florida

Real Estate Seller Disputes in Florida

In the vibrant Florida real estate market, where properties change hands regularly, seller disputes can be stumbling blocks in an otherwise smooth transaction. Navigating seller disputes requires a balanced understanding of Florida real estate law, whether it's issues with disclosures, contract breaches, or disagreements over property conditions. Here's what you need to know about common seller disputes in Florida, their legal implications, and strategies for resolution.

Discover your options, protect your interests, and ensure a smooth resolution. Consult with our experienced Sebastian real estate attorneys today to navigate the legal landscape with confidence.

Schedule A Consultation Today!

Common Seller Disputes in Florida

Misrepresentations and Non-Disclosure:

In Florida, the law imposes stringent disclosure obligations on sellers to ensure transparency and fairness in real estate transactions. The state follows a caveat emptor or "buyer beware" principle, emphasizing the seller's duty to disclose material facts that might impact the value or desirability of the property. These material facts can range from structural issues and environmental hazards to past termite infestations or neighborhood nuisances. Sellers must typically complete a comprehensive disclosure form, providing potential buyers with a detailed overview of the property's condition.

Real Estate Seller Disputes in Florida

Instances of concealment or misrepresentation in seller disclosures can lead to significant legal consequences. Concealing known defects or providing false information about the property can result in serious disputes between sellers and buyers. Common scenarios involve sellers intentionally hiding issues like water damage, faulty electrical systems, or ongoing conflicts with neighbors. Such actions not only violate ethical standards but also constitute a breach of the seller's legal duty. Buyers who discover concealed defects post-purchase may pursue legal action against the seller for damages incurred and, in some cases, seek rescission of the contract.

The legal ramifications for non-disclosure in Florida can vary, but they often include financial liabilities for the seller. Buyers have the right to seek compensation for damages resulting from non-disclosure, which may cover the cost of repairs, diminished property value, or other losses incurred due to the undisclosed issues. Additionally, sellers may face legal penalties, and their failure to disclose can become grounds for contract rescission. The severity of the consequences highlights the critical importance of adhering to disclosure obligations, promoting transparency, and fostering trust in Florida's real estate transactions.

Breach of Contract

Breach of contracts in real estate transactions can lead to complex legal situations. Understanding the details of purchase agreements is crucial for both buyers and sellers. Purchase agreements, often referred to as sales contracts or real estate contracts, outline the terms and conditions that both parties agree to when buying or selling a property. These agreements typically include details such as the following:

  • Purchase price
  • Financing terms
  • Closing date
  • Various contingencies

Common breach scenarios in real estate transactions include:

  • Failure to adhere to specified timelines
  • Non-disclosure of material defects
  • Refusal to close the sale

For example, if a seller fails to make agreed-upon repairs before the closing date or if a buyer cannot secure the promised financing, it may constitute a breach of contract. Material misrepresentations or fraud in the transaction can also lead to allegations of breach.

Buyers facing a breach of contract have several potential remedies available to them. One common remedy is specific performance, where the court orders the breaching party to fulfill their contractual obligations, such as completing the sale.

Alternatively, buyers may seek monetary damages, including compensation for financial losses incurred due to the breach. Buyers might also choose to terminate the contract, seeking a return of their earnest money or any other deposits made during the course of the transaction. Understanding the terms and conditions of the purchase agreement and seeking legal advice when breaches occur is essential to navigating these complex situations.

Property Condition Issues

Property Condition Issues

Property condition issues play a crucial role in real estate transactions, with both buyers and sellers dealing with matters of material defects and inspection contingencies. Most purchase agreements include provisions for property inspections, allowing buyers to assess the property's condition before finalizing the sale. Inspection contingencies allow buyers to identify any material defects or issues that may affect the property's value or safety. Material defects are substantial issues that weren't readily apparent and may include structural problems, significant damage, or hazardous conditions.

Sellers are typically responsible for disclosing known material defects and providing accurate information about the property's condition. Failing to disclose such issues can lead to legal complications, including allegations of fraud or misrepresentation. Sellers are encouraged to be transparent and forthcoming about the property's condition to avoid disputes and maintain a fair and ethical transaction process.

If post-sale discoveries reveal undisclosed material defects, buyers may have legal recourse. Depending on the jurisdiction and the specifics of the situation, buyers might seek remedies such as monetary compensation for repairs or, in extreme cases, rescission of the sale. Addressing property condition issues requires carefully examining the terms outlined in the purchase agreement, the extent of the defects, and the legal obligations of both parties involved in the transaction.

Title Defects

Title defects are potential issues associated with a property's ownership history or legal status that can impede the transfer of a clear and marketable title. These defects may arise from various sources, including unresolved liens, outstanding judgments, undisclosed heirs, errors in public records, or even forgeries in the chain of title. Identifying and addressing title defects is a crucial aspect of real estate transactions, ensuring that the buyer receives a property with a clean title.

Generally, it's the the seller's responsibility to clear title defects and provide the buyer with marketable title at the time of closing. Sellers are expected to resolve any outstanding issues that may cloud the title, ensuring the buyer receives the property free from encumbrances. This process often involves working with title insurance companies and conducting thorough title searches to identify and rectify any defects.

Title defects can significantly impact the closing process, potentially leading to delays or even the cancellation of the sale. Lenders typically require a clear title before approving a mortgage, and buyers rightfully demand assurance that the property they are purchasing comes with undisputed ownership rights.

Resolving title defects may involve:

  • Legal proceedings
  • Negotiations with relevant parties
  • Purchasing title insurance to protect against potential financial losses due to undiscovered defects

Addressing title issues early in the transaction process is essential for a smooth and successful real estate closing.

Failure to Deliver Possession

Failure to deliver possession happens when a seller fails to vacate the property by the agreed-upon date, hindering the buyer's ability to take possession and move into the newly acquired property. Real estate transactions typically include specific timelines and deadlines for the transfer of possession. When sellers fail to meet these commitments, legal issues can arise.

The purchase agreement typically outlines timelines for possession, indicating when the buyer is entitled to take physical possession of the property. Suppose the seller remains in the property beyond this agreed-upon date without a valid reason or an extension granted by the buyer. In that case, it constitutes a failure to deliver possession.

Legal consequences for failure to vacate can vary depending on state laws and the terms of the purchase agreement. Buyers may be entitled to compensation for any damages due to delayed possession, such as additional moving expenses or temporary housing costs. In severe cases, buyers may pursue legal action to enforce the terms of the agreement and seek remedies for their losses.

Resolving possession disputes often involves negotiation, mediation, or, in more contentious situations, legal action. Buyers may work with their real estate agents and attorneys or even seek assistance from local housing authorities to address the issue. The resolution may include financial compensation, extended leaseback agreements, or court-ordered eviction if the seller refuses to comply with the terms of the purchase agreement. Clear and well-defined terms regarding possession in the purchase agreement can help prevent such disputes and provide a framework for resolving them if they do arise.

Viable Strategies for Resolving Seller Disputes


Resolving Seller Disputes

Negotiation and mediation are effective strategies for resolving seller disputes, offering a path to an amicable resolution and avoiding lengthy legal battles and the associated costs. One of the key benefits of negotiating a settlement is that it allows both parties to reach a mutually agreeable solution that meets both their interests and concerns. This collaborative approach fosters a more positive relationship, which can be especially crucial when the buyer and seller have ongoing interactions, such as in a condominium or neighborhood setting.

Mediation is a valuable dispute resolution tool, providing a structured and neutral environment for the parties to discuss their grievances and work towards a resolution. A mediator, typically a neutral third party, facilitates the communication between the buyer and seller, guiding them toward a compromise. Mediation allows for more open and constructive dialogue, allowing the parties to express their concerns and better understand each other's perspectives.

Once negotiations or mediation result in an agreement, the next step involves drafting a settlement agreement. This legal document outlines the terms and conditions of the resolution, specifying each party's obligations and the agreed-upon remedies. A well-drafted settlement agreement helps prevent future disputes by providing a clear and comprehensive understanding of the resolution reached. Both negotiation and mediation emphasize a collaborative approach to dispute resolution, encouraging parties to find common ground and move forward without resorting to litigation.

Litigation and Court Proceedings

Sometimes, seller disputes escalate to the point where legal action becomes necessary. Common circumstances warranting litigation include breaches of contract, allegations of fraud or misrepresentation, and disagreements over specific performance. Real estate litigation in Florida typically involves filing a complaint in civil court, engaging in the discovery process to gather evidence, and presenting the case at trial. Buyers or sellers seeking damages, specific performance, or other remedies may pursue legal action to protect their interests.


Arbitration clauses are contractual provisions that specify disputes will be resolved through arbitration rather than traditional litigation. In Florida real estate contracts, parties may include an arbitration clause to streamline dispute resolution. Arbitration offers advantages such as a quicker resolution, reduced costs compared to court proceedings, and the ability to choose arbitrators with expertise in real estate matters. However, it also has limitations, including less formal discovery procedures and a more limited appellate process. Arbitration awards, once issued, are generally enforceable in Florida courts.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

ADR encompasses a holistic approach to dispute resolution, combining various methods such as mediation, arbitration, and negotiation. While mediation involves a neutral third party assisting the parties in reaching a voluntary agreement, arbitration, as mentioned earlier, employs a more structured process with a decision rendered by an arbitrator. Negotiation involves direct discussions between the parties to find common ground.

Parties can tailor ADR to real estate seller disputes by incorporating elements of each method. For instance, parties may engage in negotiation and mediation first, with arbitration as a fallback if they cannot reach an agreement. This flexible approach allows for a customized resolution process that aligns with the specific needs of the parties involved.

How a Real Estate Attorney Can Help with Seller Disputes in Florida

An experienced real estate attorney can be important in managing and resolving seller disputes in Florida. Here are several ways in which their experience can be beneficial:

Jordan Lulich
Jordan Lulich, Real Estate Attorney
  • Legal Guidance and Analysis: A seasoned real estate attorney can provide comprehensive legal guidance, analyze the specific details of the dispute, and offer insights into relevant Florida real estate laws. 
  • Negotiation and Communication: Attorneys are skilled negotiators who can engage with the opposing party on behalf of the seller. They can work to reach an amicable resolution through negotiation, addressing concerns, and finding common ground. 
  • Drafting and Reviewing Documents: Whether drafting settlement agreements, amendments to contracts, or reviewing important documents, a real estate attorney ensures that legal documents are accurately prepared and protect the seller's interests. 
  • Representation in Mediation and Arbitration: An experienced attorney can represent the seller during these alternative dispute resolution processes if mediation or arbitration becomes necessary. 
  • Litigation Support: In cases where litigation becomes necessary, a real estate attorney can provide strong representation in court. 
  • Knowledge and Experience in Real Estate Laws: Florida real estate law is complicated, and an attorney's knowledge and experience in this field is invaluable. They are up-to-date on the latest legal developments, ensuring the seller's case has a solid legal foundation.

Do You Have a Seller Dispute in Florida? Contact an Experienced Real Estate Attorney Today

As the real estate landscape continues to evolve in the Sunshine State, the potential for seller disputes persists. Suppose you encounter a seller dispute or another real estate transaction issue. In that case, having an experienced real estate attorney on your side is essential.